Rent vs buy in India: the real cost of a ₹1 crore flat
Buy a ₹1 crore flat with 20% down and an ₹80 lakh loan at 8.75% over 20 years, and the EMI is ₹70,697 a month, with ₹89.7 lakh of the total going to interest. Rent the same flat for ₹30,000 a month instead, invest everything the buyer spends beyond the rent, and after 20 years the answer turns on two numbers. If the renter’s money earns 10% a year, the flat has to appreciate faster than about 7.7% a year for buying to come out ahead; at 5% a year, the renter finishes ₹1.57 crore ahead. If the money sits in fixed deposits at 6.05%, buying wins above about 4.1%, and at 5% the buyer finishes ₹39 lakh ahead.
What decides it. Three assumptions do nearly all the work: how fast the flat appreciates, what the money a renter doesn’t put into a flat earns, and how long you stay. The loan rate matters far less: moving it from 8.75% to 9% shifts the 20-year result by ₹5 lakh to ₹9 lakh. Over ten years instead of twenty, at 5% appreciation, renting comes out ahead in this example even at FD rates, because the 7% paid in stamp duty and registration, and the interest-heavy early EMIs, have not been earned back by then.
Rates and prices in October 2026
The Reserve Bank of India raised the repo rate by 25 basis points, from 5.25% to 5.50%, at the end of its Monetary Policy Committee meeting of 5 to 7 October 2026, and changed its stance to “calibrated tightening”. Home loans linked to the repo rate move with it, and the banks’ published rates are already changing.
| Bank | Home loan rate | How it is set |
|---|---|---|
| ICICI Bank | 8.75% | Salaried borrower, credit score 750 or more; uses the 5.50% repo rate from 8 October |
| HDFC Bank | 8.00% to 13.45% | Repo rate plus 2.50 to 7.95 percentage points |
| SBI | 7.25% onwards | External benchmark still 7.90%, on the old 5.25% repo rate |
The worked example below uses 8.75%. It is a published rate that already includes the October hike, for a salaried borrower with a good credit score. SBI’s page on 12 October still built its external benchmark on the 5.25% repo rate, so its rates had not yet caught up with the hike.
The other side of the comparison is what the money would earn if it did not go into a flat. SBI’s fixed deposit rates for the general public, unchanged since 15 December 2025, are 6.25% for one to two years, 6.40% for two to three years, 6.30% for three to five years and 6.05% for five to ten years. The example uses 6.05%, the rate for the longest deposits, because the money is held for twenty years.
On prices, ANAROCK puts the average across India’s seven largest cities at ₹9,714 per sq ft in July to September 2026, 7% higher than a year earlier. Delhi-NCR averaged ₹9,980, up 12% from ₹8,900. At the seven-city average, ₹1 crore buys about 1,030 sq ft.
The worked example: one flat, two households
Assumptions. A ₹1 crore flat. The buyer pays 20% down (₹20 lakh) and 7% for stamp duty and registration (₹7 lakh), and borrows ₹80 lakh at 8.75% for 20 years. Maintenance, property tax and repairs cost 1% of the flat’s value a year, and the flat appreciates 5% a year. The renter lives in the same flat for ₹30,000 a month, rising 7% a year. The renter invests the ₹27 lakh the buyer paid upfront, plus each month’s difference between the buyer’s costs and the rent, at either 6.05% (SBI’s five-to-ten-year FD rate) or 10% (an assumption for an equity fund, not a promise). Tax is left out on both sides. The 7% and the 1% are round figures; stamp duty and registration vary by state.
These are the same method and inputs the rent vs buy calculator uses, so you can rerun the example with your own city’s numbers.
The buyer
The EMI comes from the standard formula: EMI = P × r × (1 + r)n ÷ ((1 + r)n − 1), where P is the loan, r the monthly interest rate and n the number of months. Here P is ₹80,00,000, r is 8.75% ÷ 12 = 0.72917% (0.0072917) and n is 240, so (1 + r)240 is 5.7182. The EMI is ₹80,00,000 × 0.0072917 × 5.7182 ÷ 4.7182 = ₹70,697.
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Down payment | ₹20,00,000 |
| Stamp duty and registration, at 7% | ₹7,00,000 |
| 240 EMIs of ₹70,697 | ₹1,69,67,246 |
| Of that, repaying the loan | ₹80,00,000 |
| Of that, interest | ₹89,67,246 |
| Maintenance, property tax and repairs | about ₹33.8 lakh |
| Total paid out | about ₹2.30 crore |
| What the buyer has after 20 years | A flat worth about ₹2.65 crore, with no loan |
The interest is front-loaded. In the first five years, 78% of what the buyer pays in EMIs is interest, and the loan falls only from ₹80 lakh to ₹70.7 lakh. Principal overtakes interest in month 146, early in the thirteenth year. Where your home loan EMI money actually goes walks through that schedule month by month.
The renter
The renter pays ₹30,000 a month in the first year, rising 7% a year to ₹1,08,496 a month in year 20: about ₹1.48 crore over the twenty years, with no flat at the end. What the renter has instead is the money the buyer spent and the renter didn’t. On day one that is the ₹27 lakh the buyer paid upfront. In the first month it is a further ₹49,030: the buyer’s ₹70,697 EMI and ₹8,333 of upkeep, less ₹30,000 of rent.
That monthly gap shrinks as the rent rises. From month 205, in year 18, the rent is higher than the buyer’s EMI and upkeep together, and the renter adds nothing more. From then on the buyer is the one with money to spare; the model, like the calculator, doesn’t invest it, which understates the buyer by about ₹4 lakh.
| Buyer | Renter, FDs at 6.05% | Renter, equity at 10% | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Spent on the flat | ₹2.30 crore, including the down payment | ₹1.48 crore of rent | ₹1.48 crore of rent |
| Holds at the end | Flat worth ₹2.65 crore | Investments worth ₹2.26 crore | Investments worth ₹4.22 crore |
| Who is ahead | Buyer, by ₹39 lakh | Renter, by ₹1.57 crore |
About half of the ₹1.96 crore gap between the two renter columns comes from the first cheque. The ₹27 lakh invested on day one grows to ₹87 lakh over 20 years at 6.05%, and to ₹1.82 crore at 10%.
The two numbers that decide it
Change the appreciation rate and the investment return and the result moves by crores. The loan rate, the rent and the upkeep move it by lakhs.
| Flat appreciates | Flat worth after 20 years | Renter invests at 6.05% | Renter invests at 10% |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3% a year | ₹1.81 crore | Renter, by ₹38.9 lakh | Renter, by ₹2.32 crore |
| 5% a year | ₹2.65 crore | Buyer, by ₹39.3 lakh | Renter, by ₹1.57 crore |
| 7% a year | ₹3.87 crore | Buyer, by ₹1.52 crore | Renter, by ₹47.8 lakh |
| 9% a year | ₹5.60 crore | Buyer, by ₹3.11 crore | Buyer, by ₹1.07 crore |
Solving for the rate at which the two paths finish level gives about 4.1% a year if the renter’s money earns 6.05%, and about 7.7% a year if it earns 10%. Put that way, the question is not whether renting or buying is better in general. It is whether you expect this particular flat to appreciate faster than that, and what you would really do with the money otherwise.
For scale, ANAROCK’s figures show average prices rising 47% in Delhi, 64% in Mumbai, 90% in Bengaluru, 93% in Hyderabad, 117% in Gurugram and 125% in Noida between 2019 and the second quarter of 2026. Taking that as seven years, it works out to about 5.7% a year in Delhi and 12.3% in Noida. A city average moves with the mix of projects being sold, not with the resale value of one flat, and seven years say little about the next twenty.
Rent growth matters because it decides how fast the renter’s monthly surplus shrinks. With rent rising 5% a year instead of 7%, the break-even appreciation rises to 4.9% against FDs and 8.4% against equity. With rent rising 10% a year, it falls to 3.3% and 6.9%.
The loan rate matters less than it feels when you sign. At 9% instead of 8.75%, the EMI is ₹71,978 and the interest ₹92.7 lakh, and the 20-year result moves by ₹5.3 lakh against FDs and ₹8.7 lakh against equity. Each quarter-point on an ₹80 lakh, 20-year loan is roughly ₹1,300 a month.
How long you stay changes the answer
The longer you stay, the more time appreciation has to make up for what buying costs at the start. Sell sooner and the picture changes, because the 7% paid at registration never comes back and most of the early EMIs went to interest.
| Stay | Buyer | Renter at 6.05% | Renter at 10% | Break-even appreciation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 7 years | ₹75.0 lakh (₹1.41 crore less ₹65.7 lakh owed) | ₹86.3 lakh | ₹1.05 crore | 6.2% against FDs, 8.1% against equity |
| 10 years | ₹1.06 crore (₹1.63 crore less ₹56.4 lakh owed) | ₹1.15 crore | ₹1.53 crore | 5.6% against FDs, 7.8% against equity |
| 20 years | ₹2.65 crore (loan repaid) | ₹2.26 crore | ₹4.22 crore | 4.1% against FDs, 7.7% against equity |
The shorter the stay, the higher the appreciation a buyer needs. If you may move within seven years or so, that matters more to this decision than a quarter-point on the loan.
The rent-to-price check, briefly
₹1 crore for a flat that rents at ₹30,000 a month is 333 months of rent, almost 28 years. Put the other way, a year’s rent is 3.6% of the price: the flat’s rental yield. That sits inside the range ANAROCK found for the second quarter of 2026: 3.2% in Delhi, 3.6% in Hyderabad, 3.9% in Noida, 4.3% in Gurugram and Mumbai, and 4.6% in Bengaluru. Yields in all six were higher than in 2019, which means rents there rose faster than prices. That is why the example lets rent grow faster than the flat’s value.
A yield well below the 6.05% to 6.40% SBI pays on deposits means a buyer is counting on appreciation for the rest of the return. Whether a specific asking price is defensible against its rent is a separate, quicker test, and Is that flat overpriced? Its rent already told you works through it.
What the arithmetic leaves out
Tax. The example ignores it, and it cuts both ways. Interest on fixed deposits is taxed every year at your slab rate, so at the 30% slab, 6.05% keeps about 4.2% before cess. Gains on equity funds are taxed when you sell. Under the old tax regime a buyer can deduct up to ₹2 lakh a year of interest on a home they live in; under the new regime, the default, that deduction is not available.
Discipline. The renter’s result assumes every rupee of the gap is invested every month for twenty years and never touched. An EMI forces a buyer to save; a renter’s investing has to be kept up by choice. If the difference gets spent instead, the renter’s columns in the tables above shrink towards zero.
What has no price. A landlord can ask a tenant to leave; nobody can ask an owner to. A renter can move for a job once the lease allows; an owner has a flat to sell or let first, and a flat cannot be sold in a week. Neither of these goes into the table, and both are real.
None of this says which to choose. It says what you are betting on whichever way you go.
Before comparing: what the EMI leaves you
Whichever way the comparison falls, the EMI has to fit next to everything else you pay. Four questions, answered from last month’s bank statement:
- What share of take-home pay already goes to rent or an existing EMI?
- What share goes to every other EMI, including phones, bikes and “no-cost” purchases?
- What is left for an emergency fund after both?
- What is left for investing after that?
On this example’s terms, each ₹1 lakh borrowed costs about ₹884 a month. Lenders generally approve total EMIs up to 50% to 55% of income, as the EMI-to-income ratio explainer sets out, but an approval limit is not a budget. If the four answers don’t add up, the loan on offer is a guess, and the time to find that out is before the registration fee.
Questions worth asking
What appreciation does a flat need for buying to beat renting?
In this post’s example, a ₹1 crore flat bought with 20% down and an ₹80 lakh loan at 8.75% over 20 years, against renting it for ₹30,000 a month rising 7% a year, the two paths finish level after 20 years at about 7.7% appreciation a year if the renter invests the difference at 10%. If the renter keeps the money in fixed deposits at 6.05%, they finish level at about 4.1%. Above those rates buying comes out ahead; below them renting does. Over ten years instead of twenty, the two rates rise to about 7.8% and 5.6%.
What does an ₹80 lakh home loan cost over 20 years?
At 8.75%, ICICI Bank’s rate for a salaried borrower with a credit score of 750 or more in October 2026, the EMI is ₹70,697. The 240 EMIs add up to ₹1,69,67,246, so ₹89.7 lakh of what you pay is interest. At 9% the EMI is ₹71,978 and the interest ₹92.7 lakh. Interest is front-loaded: at 8.75%, about 78% of what you pay in the first five years goes to interest.
Does it matter whether a renter invests in FDs or equity funds?
More than almost anything else in the comparison. In this post’s ₹1 crore example at 5% appreciation, a renter who puts the down payment, the stamp duty and each month’s difference into fixed deposits at SBI’s five-to-ten-year rate of 6.05% ends 20 years about ₹39 lakh behind the buyer, before tax. At an assumed 10% a year from an equity fund, the same renter ends about ₹1.57 crore ahead. Equity returns are not guaranteed, and FD interest is taxed every year at your slab rate.
What costs come on top of the EMI when buying?
Before you get the keys: the down payment, stamp duty and registration, which vary by state (this post and our calculator assume 7% of the price for the two together), GST if the flat is still under construction, and brokerage if an agent is involved. After that come maintenance, property tax and repairs for every year you own it, which this post assumes at 1% of the flat’s value a year. None of these appear in the EMI a bank quotes you.
Did the October 2026 repo rate hike make home loans costlier?
For loans linked to the repo rate, yes. The RBI raised the repo rate by 25 basis points, from 5.25% to 5.50%, at its meeting of 5 to 7 October 2026. ICICI Bank’s rates use the new 5.50% from 8 October, and HDFC Bank prices home loans at the repo rate plus 2.50 to 7.95 percentage points. SBI’s external benchmark was still 7.90%, built on the old 5.25%, as of 12 October. On an ₹80 lakh loan over 20 years, a quarter-point rise adds roughly ₹1,300 to the EMI.
How much home loan can I actually afford?
At 8.75% over 20 years, each ₹1 lakh borrowed costs about ₹884 a month. If you want the EMI to stay at 40% of a ₹1.5 lakh monthly take-home, that is ₹60,000 a month, which supports a loan of about ₹68 lakh, roughly 45 times monthly take-home. Lenders generally approve total EMIs up to 50% to 55% of income, but that limit leaves out rent, investing and an emergency fund, so treat it as a ceiling rather than a target.
Related
Before the next EMI, see what is already spoken for.
This is the audit worth running before any new EMI: what share of your income is already committed. In TLDR Classic your rent or EMI logs itself as a repeating entry and everything else is a line you type the way you’d say it, so the share is there every month. One subscription, no ads, no loans sold on the side.
Sources
- Monetary Policy Statement, 2026-27: Resolution of the Monetary Policy Committee, 5 to 7 October 2026 (repo rate raised 25 basis points to 5.50%, stance “calibrated tightening”) — Reserve Bank of India, 7 Oct 2026
- Home loan interest rates: 8.75% for salaried borrowers with a credit score of 750 or more, repo rate 5.50% from 8 October 2026 — ICICI Bank
- Home loan interest rates: policy repo rate plus 2.50% to 7.95%, or 8% to 13.45% — HDFC Bank
- Interest rates: home loans from 7.25%, external benchmark rate 7.90% (repo 5.25% plus 2.65% spread) — State Bank of India
- Retail domestic term deposits below ₹3 crore, rates from 15 December 2025 — State Bank of India
- Housing sales in top seven cities rise 3% in Q3 2026; average price ₹9,714 per sq ft, up 7% (ANAROCK Research) — Business Today, 29 Sep 2026
- Delhi-NCR housing prices up 12% in Q3 2026 to ₹9,980 per sq ft (ANAROCK) — Business Today, 5 Oct 2026
- Price growth and rental yields in six markets, 2019 to Q2 2026 (ANAROCK) — Business Today, 4 Aug 2026
Rates and prices as of 12 October 2026. Banks change their rates often, so check the lender’s own page before relying on them. This is an explanation of the arithmetic, not a recommendation about your money. TLDR Money is not a registered investment adviser and earns no commission on any product mentioned. The worked example is illustrative; your city, tax position, job security and how long you stay will change the answer.
