TLDR Money Get the app
Expense tracking · 10 min read

The ₹500 subscription trap: how to find every autopay and cancel it

Twelve subscriptions at under ₹500 each can come to ₹3,059 a month, or ₹36,708 a year, in the illustrative list below, and they leave your account through three channels: UPI AutoPay, card mandates and app-store billing. RBI’s E-mandate Framework, 2026, in force since 21 April, requires a notice at least 24 hours before each subscription debit on a card, wallet or UPI mandate, and a free way to cancel at any time. It does not make you approve each one: after the first payment, debits up to ₹15,000 go through without an OTP or PIN. The audit below finds every mandate in one sitting.

An e-mandate is a standing permission for a merchant to charge your card, prepaid wallet or UPI account on a schedule. Under RBI’s framework of 21 April 2026, the bank, card issuer or wallet that pays has to tell you at least 24 hours before each such debit, except FASTag and NCMC top-ups, and again after it. You can skip one debit or cancel the whole mandate at any time, at no charge, confirming with an OTP or PIN. The ₹15,000 figure often quoted is not a threshold for the notice. It is how large a recurring debit can be without a fresh OTP or PIN, and it has not changed since 2022.

Twelve small charges, ₹36,708 a year

None of these charges looks like much on its own, which is the problem. Here is an ordinary list for one household: streaming, music, cloud storage, a couple of memberships and a few apps. Each costs less than ₹500 a month.

An illustrative list of twelve recurring charges for one household. Prices are typical monthly list-price points for each category in India as of October 2026, not any provider’s actual price; your services and prices will differ.
ChargeA monthBilled through, in this example
Video streaming, standard plan₹499Card mandate
Video streaming, mobile-only plan₹149UPI AutoPay
Sports streaming₹299UPI AutoPay
Music streaming₹119App Store or Google Play
Cloud storage for phone backup₹219App Store or Google Play
Cloud storage for email and photos₹130UPI AutoPay
Shopping membership with free delivery₹299UPI AutoPay
Food delivery membership₹149Card mandate
Fitness app₹399App Store or Google Play
Office and productivity software₹349Card mandate
News subscription₹199Card mandate
Language-learning app₹249App Store or Google Play
Total, twelve charges₹3,059 

That is ₹36,708 a year, or about ₹255 a charge on average. The list splits evenly across the three places recurring charges live: four on card mandates (₹1,196 a month), four on UPI AutoPay (₹877) and four billed through the App Store or Google Play (₹986). Each place keeps its own list and no single screen shows all twelve, which is how a subscription outlives the reason you bought it.

How many people pay for subscriptions they don’t use

The best Indian evidence comes from two surveys. In February 2024 YouGov asked people in urban India about their subscriptions. Of those who had any, 23% said two of them had gone unused in the past six months, 9% had four unused, and 7% said more than five. Of the 17 markets surveyed, India and Mexico were the most likely to have two unused subscriptions.

LocalCircles collected more than 44,000 responses from users of app and software subscriptions in 331 districts between 1 December 2023 and 30 January 2024. Of those who had bought through apps or software platforms, 67% said something sold as a one-time purchase had often turned out to be a subscription trap, and 71% had met hidden charges that appeared only at payment. On 30 November 2023 the Central Consumer Protection Authority had notified a ban on dark patterns, and the subscription trap is one of the 13 it names.

One figure needs care: the claim that 42% of people pay for a subscription they have forgotten. It comes from C+R Research, which surveyed 1,000 consumers in the United States between 22 April and 2 May 2022. Forty-two per cent said they had stopped using a subscription but forgot they were still paying. On average they guessed they spent $86 a month on subscriptions, and itemised $219. We found no Indian survey that measures forgotten payments the same way, so there is no Indian equivalent to quote. An earlier version of this post used the 42% without saying it was a US figure.

What an e-mandate is

An e-mandate is a standing instruction you approve once, letting a merchant charge you again and again without asking each time. RBI’s framework covers three instruments: cards, prepaid payment instruments such as wallets, and UPI, where the same thing is called AutoPay. On cards it is often called a standing instruction.

A mandate can be for a fixed amount, like a ₹149 monthly plan, or a variable one, like a utility bill, up to a ceiling. For a variable mandate the issuer has to let you set that maximum yourself. Every mandate has a validity period, which you can change, and you can withdraw the mandate at any time.

Setting one up takes an additional factor of authentication (AFA), such as an OTP on a card or your UPI PIN, and the first debit needs one too. After that, debits go through on their own up to a limit, which is why a renewal can arrive without you doing anything.

The framework names cards, prepaid instruments and UPI only. Direct debits from a bank account through NACH, the route many loan EMIs and SIPs use, run under separate rules that this post doesn’t cover.

What RBI’s 2026 e-mandate framework requires

RBI issued Digital Payments – E-mandate Framework, 2026 (RBI/DPSS/2026-27/396) on 21 April 2026, effective the same day. Its press release describes the framework as a consolidation of the instructions already in force, with a few changes made after feedback from the industry. Much of what follows was already the rule; the framework puts it in one place.

What the E-mandate Framework, 2026 requires of the bank, card issuer or wallet that pays a recurring debit. Source: RBI notification of 21 April 2026.
RuleWhat the framework says
Who it coversRecurring payments on cards, prepaid payment instruments and UPI, within India or across borders
Setting upThe mandate is registered only after AFA, and the first debit needs AFA too
Before each debitA notice at least 24 hours ahead, giving the merchant’s name, the amount, the date and time, the mandate’s reference number and the reason. Not required for FASTag or NCMC top-ups
Skipping or cancellingYou can opt out of any single debit or the whole mandate, confirmed with AFA, and change the validity period or withdraw the mandate at any time
After each debitA notice with the merchant’s name, the amount, the date and time, and how to complain
Debits without an OTP or PINUp to ₹15,000 a transaction, or ₹1,00,000 for insurance premiums, mutual fund subscriptions and credit card bills. Anything larger needs AFA each time
Variable amountsYou can set the maximum any one debit can be
Cost to youNothing: no charge to the customer for using e-mandates

The two limits are older than the framework. RBI set ₹15,000 for debits without AFA in June 2022, and in December 2023 raised it to ₹1,00,000 for mutual fund subscriptions, insurance premiums and credit card bills. The 2026 framework carried both over unchanged.

A correction. An earlier version of this post said the 24-hour notice applied only to debits above ₹15,000. That was wrong. The notice is required before every debit the framework covers, other than FASTag and NCMC top-ups; ₹15,000 is the limit for debits without an OTP or PIN.

What the notice gives you is a 24-hour window. A message that names the merchant, the amount and the date is the moment to decide, and opting out of that debit or the whole mandate takes an OTP or PIN and costs nothing. What it does not do is wait for an answer: ignore the notice, and the debit goes through.

Does UPI AutoPay cost anything?

Not to you: the framework bars any charge to the customer for the e-mandate facility. It doesn’t cost the merchant a UPI fee either. NPCI’s FAQ on the new merchant discount rate, published on 15 September 2026, says payments through UPI mandates and AutoPay, including OTT subscriptions, utility bills and recurring investments, carry no prescribed rate. The 0.4% fee on other eligible merchant payments above ₹2,000 is officially due from 15 October 2026, though a delay was under discussion as of 12 October. The UPI rule changes, sorted by status, has where that stands.

How to see and cancel your mandates

UPI AutoPay

Open each UPI app you have paid a subscription through and look for a section called AutoPay or Mandates, usually under your profile or payment settings. Each active mandate shows the merchant, the amount or the maximum, how often it runs and when it ends. Depending on the app, you can pause a mandate or cancel it; cancelling asks for your UPI PIN, the additional factor the framework requires. A mandate is usually managed from the app it was set up in, so a second or third UPI app can hold mandates the first one doesn’t show.

Card standing instructions

Card mandates sit with the bank or company that issued the card, not with the merchant. Look in the issuer’s app or net banking for a section named standing instructions, e-mandates or recurring payments; the name differs by issuer. The framework requires the issuer to let you withdraw a mandate at any time and to opt out of any single debit, so if you can’t find the option, the issuer’s customer care is the next place to ask. Check every card, including ones you rarely use: a card in a drawer still pays its subscriptions.

App Store and Google Play

Subscriptions bought inside an app are billed by Apple or Google, not by the app’s maker. On an iPhone they are in Settings, under your name, then Subscriptions. On Android, open the Play Store, tap your profile picture, then Payments and subscriptions, then Subscriptions. Cancel the individual subscription there. On your card or UPI list, several of these can sit behind one mandate to Apple or Google, so that mandate is the wrong place to cancel just one of them.

Cancelling at both ends

Cancelling a mandate stops the money. It does not always close your account with the service, which may keep sending payment reminders or try another payment method saved with it. Cancelling inside the service as well closes both ends.

A subscription audit, step by step

The places above, plus your statements and your inbox, hold every recurring charge you have. Going through them in this order takes one sitting.

  1. List your UPI mandates. In each UPI app, open AutoPay or Mandates and note the merchant, amount, frequency and next debit date.
  2. List your card mandates. In each card issuer’s app or net banking, open the standing-instruction or e-mandate page for every card you hold.
  3. Open your app-store subscriptions. iPhone: Settings, your name, Subscriptions. Android: Play Store, profile picture, Payments and subscriptions, Subscriptions.
  4. Search your email for “renewal”, “receipt”, “subscription” and “auto-debit” over the past 12 months. Annual plans renew once a year, so a 90-day search misses them.
  5. Scan three months of bank and card statements for any merchant that appears in more than one month. A repeating line is a subscription even when its description doesn’t say so.
  6. Mark each charge keep, downgrade or cancel. One test is whether you opened it in the last 30 days. Downgrading keeps the service at a lower price: from the standard streaming plan in the table to a mobile-only one, ₹499 to ₹149, is ₹350 a month less.
  7. Cancel at both ends, then watch for notices. Cancel the mandate and the subscription inside the service. If a pre-debit notice still arrives for it, the mandate is still live, and you have 24 hours to opt out of that debit.

What two unused subscriptions cost over time

Worked example, with its assumptions. Two of the twelve charges go unused: the fitness app at ₹399 and the language-learning app at ₹249, the pattern 23% of urban Indian subscribers reported to YouGov. That is ₹648 a month, or ₹7,776 a year, and the prices stay flat. The comparison column assumes the same ₹648 is invested at the start of each month instead, earning 10% a year compounded monthly. The 10% is an assumption for illustration, not a forecast of any investment’s return.

Two unused subscriptions at ₹648 a month. Paid: ₹648 × 12 × years. Invested: 10% a year compounded monthly, paid in at the start of each month.
AfterPaid for unused subscriptionsThe same money at an assumed 10% a year
10 years₹77,760₹1,33,846
20 years₹1,55,520₹4,96,172
30 years₹2,33,280₹14,77,003

No one keeps the same unused app for 30 years. The habit lasts longer than any one subscription, though: cancel one, and a free trial that converts can take its place. Across all twelve charges in the list, ₹3,059 a month comes to ₹11,01,240 over 30 years before any growth.

After the audit, the notice is the checkpoint

An audit is a snapshot. The pre-debit notice is the prompt that recurs: each debit on a card, wallet or UPI mandate, other than FASTag and NCMC top-ups, has to be announced a day ahead. A notice you don’t recognise is the cue to opt out of that debit and find out what it is.

Charges on a credit card also show up on the statement, where a free trial that converted reads like any other recurring line; reading a credit card statement line by line shows where to look. And the ways of tracking expenses in India differ mainly in what they ask you to hand over, but every one of them needs the list of recurring charges this audit produces.

Questions worth asking

Does RBI require a warning before a subscription auto-renews?

Yes, for mandates on cards, prepaid wallets and UPI. RBI’s E-mandate Framework, 2026 requires the issuer to send a notice at least 24 hours before each debit, naming the merchant, the amount, the date and time, the mandate’s reference number and the reason, and to let you opt out of that debit or the whole mandate. FASTag and NCMC top-ups are exempt, and bank-account debits through NACH are outside the framework.

Why did my subscription renew without an OTP?

Because after the first payment, RBI lets recurring e-mandate debits go through without an additional factor of authentication up to ₹15,000 a transaction, or ₹1,00,000 for insurance premiums, mutual fund subscriptions and credit card bills. The ₹15,000 limit dates from June 2022 and the ₹1 lakh limit from December 2023; the 2026 framework kept both. The issuer still has to notify you at least 24 hours before the debit, and again after it.

How do I cancel a UPI AutoPay mandate?

Open the UPI app the mandate was set up in, go to its AutoPay or Mandates section, choose the merchant and cancel. The app asks for your UPI PIN, the additional authentication RBI requires for any cancellation, and you cannot be charged for it. Cancelling stops future debits but may not close your account with the service, so cancelling there too ends both. If you have used more than one UPI app, check each.

Do UPI AutoPay subscriptions attract the new 0.4% merchant fee?

No. NPCI’s FAQ on the merchant discount rate for UPI, published on 15 September 2026, says payments through UPI mandates and AutoPay carry no prescribed rate, whatever the amount. The 0.4% applies to other eligible merchant payments above ₹2,000 and is officially due from 15 October 2026, though a delay was under discussion as of 12 October. Customers pay nothing either way: RBI bars any charge to them for the e-mandate facility.

How many Indians pay for subscriptions they don’t use?

No survey measures it exactly, but two come close. In YouGov’s February 2024 survey of urban India, 23% of people with subscriptions had two they had not used in six months. In a LocalCircles survey with more than 44,000 responses, 67% of people who bought through apps said a one-time purchase had turned out to be a subscription trap. The widely quoted 42% who forgot they were still paying comes from a 2022 US survey.

What’s the fastest way to audit my own subscriptions?

Check the places recurring charges live: each UPI app’s AutoPay or Mandates list, every card issuer’s standing-instruction or e-mandate page, and the App Store or Google Play subscriptions screen. Then scan three months of bank and card statements for any merchant that appears in more than one month, and search your email for “renewal” and “receipt” over the past year to catch annual plans. Mark each charge keep, downgrade or cancel.

Related

Keep the list after the audit

The catch with a one-time audit: it works once. In TLDR Classic, set each subscription as a repeating entry and it logs itself every month, and the Recurring screen lists everything going out on autopilot. The only one that escapes is the one you never add. Every new account gets Pro free for 30 days, no card needed.

Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store

Sources

Rules as of 12 October 2026. The prices in the tables are illustrative, not any provider’s current price, and the 10% return is an assumption, not a forecast. This is an explanation of how e-mandates work, not advice about your money. TLDR Money is not a registered investment adviser and earns no commission on any service mentioned.