₹1.8 lakh crore · SEBI, FY22–FY24
93% of F&O traders in India lost money. The 7% weren’t smarter.
Between FY22 and FY24, 1.13 crore Indians traded futures and options. 93% lost money. Total losses: ₹1.8 lakh crore.
The 7% who made money weren’t smarter, faster, or running a better strategy. They understood one thing the other 93% didn’t — and it has nothing to do with charts.
The word everyone uses and nobody defines
“Calculated risk” gets said constantly and explained rarely. Calculated risk is when you’ve already decided what happens if you lose. Everything else is theatre.
Think of it as jumping out of a plane. With a parachute, or without one. Both are risky and both can end badly, but only one comes with a plan if it goes wrong — and that plan, not the asset or the expected return, is the only real difference between an investor and a gambler.
Putting ₹2 lakh into a small-cap because a cousin said it would 5x is jumping without a parachute. Putting ₹10,000 a month into a Nifty 50 index fund, knowing full well the market has fallen 50%+ before and will again, is jumping with one.
Not taking risk is also a risk
Keeping everything in a savings account paying around 3%, while inflation runs near 6%, isn’t safety. It’s a loss you simply can’t see happening in real time.
There are really two kinds of risk running in parallel in your life. Career risk — where your salary comes from, the skill you’re building. And investment risk — what you do with that salary once it lands. Both compound. Both need five to ten years to actually show up. Most people obsess over the second and ignore the first, which is backwards: your career — the next promotion, the skill that makes you hard to replace — compounds faster than any SIP for the first decade.
Why 9 out of 10 lose
SEBI ran the numbers directly. Between FY22 and FY24, 1.13 crore individual traders touched futures and options. 93% lost money. The top 3.5% of losers — roughly 4 lakh people — lost an average of ₹28 lakh each.
| Metric | Figure |
|---|---|
| Individual traders | 1.13 crore |
| Share that lost money | 93% |
| Aggregate losses | ₹1.8 lakh crore |
| Top 3.5% of losers, average loss each | ₹28 lakh |
None of it comes down to “the market is rigged.” Three reasons recur. No emergency fund, so a trade going wrong forced an exit at the worst possible moment because rent was due. No asset allocation, so when Nifty fell roughly 38% in 46 trading days during March 2020, there was nothing else to balance it. And copying someone else’s trade — a YouTuber, a friend, a Telegram channel — whose EMIs, timeline and risk tolerance were never the same as theirs.
The parachute, actually
What it takes is boring. None of it will go viral.
- Six months of expenses, in cash. Not equity, not a liquid fund you’ll be tempted to dip into. On ₹40,000 a month, that’s ₹2.4 lakh sitting in a savings account, doing nothing exciting.
- A debt-to-income ratio under 33%. All EMIs combined — bike, phone, the no-cost fridge — under a third of in-hand. Past that, there’s no room for investment risk because life risk is already maxed out.
- Real asset allocation. Not 100% equity. In 2008, Nifty fell roughly 65% peak to trough — a pure-equity ₹10,000 portfolio would have dropped to about ₹3,500. The same portfolio with a meaningful gold allocation lost closer to 17%.
- Time. Nifty 50’s 10-year rolling CAGR has never gone negative — through 2008, the dot-com bust, COVID — averaging around 11%. That only holds if you actually stay in for ten years. Panic-sell in year two and you lock in the loss and miss the recovery entirely.
And if the pull towards F&O is really a wish for something more active than an index fund, there is now a regulated route to it. A specialized investment fund sits in the gap SEBI identified between a mutual fund and a PMS, and is allowed to run strategies a mutual fund is not. It asks ₹10 lakh to get in — a floor that is doing deliberate work, because it keeps the strategies away from money that cannot afford to sit still.
The three-question check
Open a banking app and answer these in under sixty seconds:
- Monthly expenses × 6 — is that sitting in cash right now?
- What % of in-hand goes to EMIs? Past 33%, fix that before adding investment risk — the same math shows up when EMI interest outpaces SIP returns.
- How many different asset classes is your money actually spread across? If it’s one, that’s not investing. That’s a bet.
If those don’t come easily, the risk on the table isn’t calculated.
This is the picture TLDR is being built to show: your real monthly expense, your actual EMI ratio, and how your money is split across asset classes — before you put another rupee into anything.
Join the waitlistWe’ll email you when it’s ready. No spam, ever.
Individual circumstances vary considerably — income stability, existing obligations, and genuine risk tolerance all change what the right allocation is. This is an explanation of how the arithmetic and the history work, not investment advice.
Sources
- SEBI, “Updated SEBI study reveals 93% of individual traders incurred losses in equity F&O between FY22 and FY24”, September 2024 — sebi.gov.in
- SEBI, “Comparative Study of Growth in Equity Derivatives Segment vis-à-vis Cash Market”, July 2025 — sebi.gov.in
- BMS Money, “Decades of Nifty 50 Performance” (10-year rolling CAGR analysis, 1991–2024) — bmsmoney.com
- MoneyVesta, “Nifty 50 Drawdowns and Recoveries” (2008 and COVID crash data) — moneyvesta.com
- RBI, Financial Stability Report, June 2025 (debt-to-income benchmark) — rbidocs.rbi.org.in
FAQ
What is calculated risk in investing?
Calculated risk means you’ve already decided what happens if you lose — before you put the money in, not after. It’s the difference between jumping out of a plane with a parachute and without one: both are risky, but only one has a plan for what goes wrong. In investing terms, that plan is an emergency fund, a debt load you can actually service, and money spread across more than one asset class.
Why do 90%+ of F&O traders lose money in India?
SEBI’s own study found 93% of individual F&O traders lost money between FY22 and FY24, for three recurring reasons: no emergency fund (forcing an exit at the worst possible moment), no asset allocation (100% of their money in one bet), and copying someone else’s trade without that person’s income, EMIs, or timeline.
How much emergency fund should I keep before investing?
Six months of expenses, held in cash — not equity, not even a liquid fund you might be tempted to dip into. On ₹40,000 a month in expenses, that’s ₹2.4 lakh sitting in a savings account, doing nothing exciting and making every other financial decision safer.
Is keeping all my money in a savings account safe?
Not really. A savings account paying around 3% while inflation runs near 6% is a slow, invisible loss — you’re just not watching it happen the way you’d watch a stock chart. Not taking any investment risk is still a risk; the choice is which kind of risk to take, and how much.
Start understanding your money today
Funded by subscription when it arrives — no ads, no referrals, no commissions. Nothing is charged today.
Join the waitlist